Legal Updates

I’d like to update you on five cases and the part Doctors for Life is playing in each.

1. Dignity SA – euthanasia. Attorney Martus de Wet and Adv Reg Willis SC are preparing to file our application to join as a co-respondent. The other respondents’ answering affidavits are due in March or April 2027. If the court allows us to join, we expect the same deadline to apply to us.
2. Nurse suspended without pay. On 12 and 13 November, Attorney Martus de Wet and Adv Keith Matthee SC will represent the nurse at the bargaining council in KwaZulu-Natal. She was suspended without pay for refusing to participate in an abortion. Her legal team will seek a directive to prevent similar unfair labour practices. Dr Tseliso Nkuebe of Doctors for Life will testify about systemic failures in KZN public hospitals, the humanity of the unborn child and the harm women can experience after elective abortions.
3. Mokoena – Supreme Court of Appeal. We’ve briefed Adv Khomotso Nhlapo-Merabe in Bloemfontein and obtained expert evidence on gender transition in prison. The appeal record is due to be filed in November. Once it is filed, we have 30 days to apply for admission as a friend of the court.
4. Detransitioner’s damages claim. The plaintiff is claiming damages from seven health professionals for treatment received during transition. All seven have entered an appearance to defend. The plaintiff’s legal team is applying for an order to protect the plaintiff’s identity. The team is also dealing with the medical records and evidence under the court rules, after which the defendants are expected to file their pleas. Counsel are Adv Reg Willis SC and Adv Andrew Campbell. Doctors for Life is willing to assist with expert evidence if needed.
5. Hoërskool Stellenbosch – Equality Court. A former learner who was born male and identified as a girl at school has taken the school’s governing body and others to the Equality Court. The case concerns the role schools should play in the social transition of learners with gender dysphoria, including how schools respond to requests about uniforms, pronouns and access to facilities. Doctors for Life was admitted as a friend of the court in February 2026. The October hearing was postponed because the applicants needed more time to obtain expert evidence and several parties and friends of the court had been permitted to make submissions. The matter is now set down for April or May 2027 before three judges of the Western Cape High Court in Cape Town. Attorney Martus de Wet and Adv Kobus Griessel represent us.

Thank you for your support and prayers. Please remember the nurse and Dr Nkuebe in particular as they prepare for the hearing on 12 and 13 November.

Dr Albu van Eeden
Doctors for Life International